Thus begins a continuing series of posts where Rob and I make our best argument for cities we don’t live in, but are in close proximity to.
This week’s topic: WINDY CITY MASS TRANSIT vs. ROCK CITY GRIDLOCK
OPENING STATEMENTS
Jeff: Two years ago I sojourned to the White City in search of an economy that couldn’t be held hostage by a group of overweight, middle aged men who think on-the-clock drunken high-lo racing is the sport of kings. My first experience with this wonderful city was in her underbelly, riding the subways and the “el”. My only experience with mass-transit before was on systems in second rate cities, places like London, Paris and Berlin. Let me tell you, Chicago puts every other city on the face of the earth to shame. To shame, I say!
Rob: Being a world-traveler myself, I’ve experienced mass transit in quite a few metropolises. And since Detroit has no mass transit whatsoever, save the People Mover (blech), I’m here to say we don’t need it. Having lived with and without it…well, you can keep your stupid, dependable modes of transport! You hear me, world! We’re better off without it! Give me a gas-guzzling, environment polluting automobile any day of the week. Trolleys and trams, subways and buses - blech! After all, we’re all out to take care of ourselves anyway, right?
ONBOARD BATHROOMS
Jeff: Gotta go? Go in your pants! In Chicago, it’s socially acceptable to crap your pants on the train, as evidenced by the toothless grin and earthy fragrance that greeted me when I stepped on my very first rail car. Finally, a place where we can be unencumbered by an unnecessary, time consuming trip to the porcelain throne.
Rob: The People Mover, a two-car elevated train that goes in a quarter-mile loop, has no bathrooms. It’s dangerous and smelly and I’m assuming bums piss all they want in there with no repercussions. I can rightfully assume, as in Chicago, there are no agents of the law making rounds to remedy this self-defecating situation, so I guess this one’s a tie. Now, the beauty of “taking care of business” in the privacy of your own car? No one else cares! If you can put up with it, what else do you need. Besides, the beauty of driving your own car means you can pull off on the shoulder to do your thing any time you want! No longer will you feel embarrassed for pulling the cord and getting off five stops early to the chagrin of those commuters you see every day. They know you have to go. They just know it.
WORLD-CLASS EFFICIENCY
Jeff: Other cities give you seats, ample standing room and enough trains to lessen the crush a hundred thousand people trying to get through the same five foot wide door. Not Chicago. Space is maximized by encouraging everyone to shove in until the very act of breathing may cause the car to explode. Bonus! You can have guilt-free sex with 6 people on the way to work. Informing them of what you did is optional.
Rob: Well, efficiency has many different meanings, my friend. Detroit has miles and miles of highway, so even though you may be late for that super urgent appointment, or you’ve completely abandoned all hope you’ll get off of I-75 before you die, at least, when you’re in your own car and stuck in traffic (which you will be, guaranteed), it seems like you’re surrounded by so many friends, each in the very same predicament you are! Efficiency of the heart, my friends.
ALWAYS ON SCHEDULE
Jeff: A Chicago bus or train is never late or early, it arrives exactly when it means too. And sometimes, 4 or 5 buses come bunched up together. The full ones stop, the empty ones skip by you so the driver can take an extra five-minute break hitting on the 200-pound honey selling deep-dish sausage pizza on Wacker. With these kinds of choices, I quickly fell under the “Lady by the Lake’s” spell.
Rob: Well, here in Motown, we do away with schedules altogether! I mean, hell, there could be a strike at any minute from any number of unions impeding your journey, and wait long enough, chances are your job will become obsolete and you won’t even have to drive anywhere! It’s like the best kind of vacation, the kind that doesn’t end!
PEOPLE LOOK OUT FOR EACH OTHER
Jeff: Whether you’re 95, you’re 8 months pregnant, you’re trying to get your 5 kids down to the soup kitchen so you can eat, or even on crutches - rest assured no one will get up to give you a seat. What doesn’t kill you, makes you stronger. And Chicago is not a city for the weak. Tough it out, or we will feast on your flesh.
Seriously, Chicagoans will eat you.
Rob: Imagine you’re at any number of fantastic clubs in downtown Detroit. It’s Friday, everyone’s bumping and grinding, and someone pulls out a gun, starts laying waste to the bodies on the floor. Then, out of pure kindness, someone is fantastic enough to start shouting “Gun! Gun! Get the f&$% out of the way! He’s got a gun!” alerting you to the situation at hand because you’ve been otherwise preoccupied with an exceptional “Detroit Hunny.” Then, the bandit leaves the club, he’s fled on one of the cities dozens of buses, the excitement’s died down, and the club starts hopping again. I mean, that kind of entertainment…you’d pay through the roof for that most places. All thanks to transportation.
CONCLUSION
In the battle of transportation, who wins? Only you, dear reader, can decide. Cast your vote in the comments or perish.